Catherine Sevenau

Opener of doors, teller of tales, family scribe.

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • YouTube
  • Home
  • Genealogy
  • Memoir Serial
  • Behind Doors/book
    • Blog
    • Purchase
  • Queen Bee/Book
    • Purchase
  • Kudos
  • Events
  • Author
  • Contact
You are here: Home / THROUGH ANY GIVEN DOOR (web serial) / Web Serial: Part I, Faded Snapshots / 3. Sonora 1948-1953 / 1.33 Benedict Arnold & Eleanor Roosevelt

1.33 Benedict Arnold & Eleanor Roosevelt

August 6, 2017 By Catherine Sevenau

“Bettyyyy. Claudiaaa.” Mother’s nightly yell for supper bounced across the yard until it floated down to the soft shadows of the creek where the girls fooled away their afternoons with tadpoles, skimmers, and leaf-hoppers. Betty paid no attention to Mom whatsoever. Claudia, emptying her large Mason jar full of polliwogs back into the creek, was compelled to respond to the summons and ran home. She’d come bounding barefoot across the creaky wooden porch, wiping the damp dirt from her hands on her cotton jumper, the front screen door banging behind her.

Turning from her task of peeling potatoes at the sink, it was always the same routine: Mom asking Claudia “Where’s Betty?” and Claudia saying, “Down at the creek,” and Mom saying, “Well, go get her and tell her to get in here,” and Claudia scuttling back to notify Betty that Mom said to come home right now.

Claudia

Betty, busy picking blackberries, screwed up her mouth, bit her lower lip, balled up her right fist, and punched Benedict Arnold on the arm for ratting on her. This confused Claudia. Why did she have to come when called, tell the truth when asked, not backtalk when told what to do? She often wondered, where was her free will?

Betty

This was about the time it dawned on Claudia that girls were inferior to boys. Boys were allowed to stay out later, girls had to be in before dark. Boys could be altar boys, girls weren’t allowed in the sacristy. Boys got to play baseball, football, and basketball; dodgeball was the only sport girls had. Men were principals, women teachers. Men were doctors, women nurses. Men owned the law firms and the stores and the banks and women were the clerks and the salesgirls and the hired help. It was a given that God was a man. There were no prominent women anywhere in history, not anyone really important that Claudia knew. Maybe Eleanor Roosevelt, but that was only because she’d been the wife of the President. Mrs. Roosevelt never held a paying job and she had a slew of kids to boot, which simply proved Claudia’s point. As it didn’t escape my sister that it was a man’s world and that men were in charge of everything it stood to reason that men must also be smarter. From early on these beliefs were firmly embedded in her, like cement pilings buried in bedrock. Doubt did not creep in until after she’d been married a couple of years.

When she was about seven, Claudia and her friend Linda Graves, a chubby girl with a head of long dark curls which she wore in two thick braids, sat cross-legged on the living room rug. Claudia, squarely facing her sock-monkey propped up with its back against the maroon Chesterfield, was patiently instructing it on the finer points of have and got and five apples minus three apples.

Linda Graves

Linda informed Claudia, “When I grow up I want to be a mother and have two babies, a boy first and then a girl.”
My sister replied, “I’m going to be a teacher.”

Dad, walking by in the adjoining dining room, happened to overhear. “I wouldn’t waste the money putting a girl through college,” he injected into their conversation, catching Claudia’s eye, “You’ll just wind up getting married and having babies.”

Her face fell. Claudia hadn’t even considered that she’d grow up, get married, and have children. Even with his remark, she still didn’t consider it a possibility. But right then and there she gave up her idea of teaching and adjusted her goals to a less lofty height. She thought, “Then maybe I’ll be a secretary, or work in a bank.”

She buried way down deep in her soul her dream of growing up and being a teacher. But sixty years later, her dream was still there. I know, because she told me.

to be continued …

© 2017. Catherine Sevenau.
All rights reserved.

Share this:

  • Share
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Pocket
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Tweet

Like this:

Like Loading...

Comments

  1. Geoffrey Elliot says

    December 4, 2017 at 2:08 pm

    Having only brothers (and being mostly oblivious to the world) I missed the whole “girls can only be…” conversation. And then, in college, I hung out with the women who had bypassed that limitation and were moving on in the world. So, your telling of Claudia’s story brought tears to my eyes; sorrow for her lost dreams. A moving story!

  2. Susan Price says

    August 8, 2017 at 5:28 pm

    I was to go to college because educated mothers were better mothers. And, a woman needed to have a backup plan in case something happened to her husband. Becoming a teacher was a great back up plan. And for that you needed an education. So I was informed that I would live at home and attend Cal State Fullerton which I could drive to in the family station wagon. And I would also drive to my parttime job filing information at the local credit bureau after my classes. Several of us college student women filed at the credit bureau in the evenings. One day the boss took us students to lunch at a restaurant where there was an afternoon show of women walking around modeling lingerie.

    • Catherine Sevenau says

      August 8, 2017 at 8:14 pm

      Your parents were more enlightened than mine. At least they prepared you for the future and your ability t take care of yourself. Love the lingerie part. Your boss missed the enlightenment conversation.

  3. Susan Davidson Dalberg says

    August 6, 2017 at 5:49 pm

    The common thought was if you went to college it was to be a teacher or a nurse. My sister wanted to go into the Air Force, like Daddy. You’d have thought she was asking to join to fight in Korea. Both parents were hysterical–although she had already enlisted in Civil Air Patrol and excelled. How thrilling what the girls can do now! Men still have the edge though.

  4. Jim Chatfield says

    August 6, 2017 at 3:16 pm

    Yes, in the old days it was a boys world. Boys got their bikes first, got their car first, stayed up later, but then they also got in more trouble.

  5. Linda Troolin says

    August 6, 2017 at 12:47 pm

    Poor Claudia. Dad’s were much alike in that era. My dad wanted me to be a telephone operator. I wanted to become a teacher and did. My father also footed the bill until I married.

    • Barbara Jacobsen says

      August 6, 2017 at 3:45 pm

      Thank goddess that changed in our lifetime. I wanted to go to art school but had to get a teaching credential instead (which turned out to be a good thing), with further instructions to marry a rich or potentially rich man. I got that part right, just wish they’d included “nice” and “kind”.

Through Any Given Door

Web Serial

Blog Sign-up

Through Any Given Door

  • Web Serial: Part I, Faded Snapshots
    • Complete Part I
    • 1. Front Matter
      • 0.i Teller of Tales, Family Line
      • 0.ii Ded, Billet-Doux, Credits, ToC
      • 0.iii Prologue
    • 2. Sonora 1943-1947
    • 3. Sonora 1948-1953
    • 4. History and Backstory
  • Web Serial: Part II, Torn Pictures
    • Complete Part II, sans photos
    • 1. San Jose, San Francisco 1954-1957
    • 2. Hawaii 1957-1958
  • Web Serial: Part III, Home Movies
    • Complete Part III, sans photos
    • La Habra, San Francisco, San Jose 1958-1968
    • Post Memoir Sketches
  • Through Any Given Door, Part I (in full)

Front Matter

0.ii Dedications, Billet-Doux, Credits

0.iii Prologue

Sonora 1943-1947

1.01 Part I, Faded Snapshots, Sonora

1.02 104 Green Street

1.03 A Chicken Named Blackie

1.04 Lucky Strike Girl

1.05 Summer Camping

1.06 Chico and Grandma Chatfield

1.07 Itty-Bitty Balls of Fluff

1.08 Might as Well be Hung for a Sheep

1.09 Brandi’s and Bingo

1.10 Wolf at the Door

1.11 Nothing But the Best

1.12 Larry’s New Diary, Jan 1947

1.13 Larry’s Diary, Feb-Mar 1947

1.14 Heathens and Hellions

1.15 Larry’s Diary, Apr-May 1947

1.16 Missive to Marceline

1.17 A California Thistle

1.18 We Love Milkshakes!

1.19 Larry’s Diary, Jun-Jul 1947

1.20 Larry’s Diary, Aug-Sep 1947

1.21 Larry’s Diary, Oct 1947

1.22 Brusha, Brusha, Brusha …

1.23 Larry’s Diary, Nov 1947

1.24 Larry’s Diary, Dec 1947

Sonora 1948-1953

1.25 Larry’s Diary, Jan-Jul 1948

1.26 1948 Small Town Gossip

1.27 Plucked From the Womb

1.28 Death of Gordon Chatfield

1.29 Larry’s Diary, Mar 1949

1.30 Larry’s Diary, Apr 1949

1.31 Larry’s Diary, May 1949

1.32 Dad, God, and the Holy Ghost

1.33 Benedict Arnold & Eleanor Roosevelt

1.34 Larry’s Diary, Jun 1949

1.35 Larry’s Diary, Jul 1949

1.36 Holy Cards, Hell, and High Water

1.37 Larry’s Diary, Aug 1949

1.38 Buck Fever, Sep 1949

1.39 Larry’s Diary, Oct 1949

1.40 Larry’s Diary, Nov 1949

1.41 Larry’s Diary, Dec 1949

1.42 The Sight of Blood

1.43 Larry’s Diary, Apr 1950; Don’t Go

1.44 Larry’s Diary, May 1950

1.45 Larry’s Diary, Jun 1950

1.46 Larry’s Diary, July 1950

1.47 Summer 1950, Bounty Hunter

1.48 Larry’s Diary, Aug 1950

1.49 Larry’s Diary, Sep 1950

1.50 Larry’s Diary, Oct 1950

1.51 Larry’s Diary, Nov 1950

1.52 Larry’s Diary, Dec 1950

1.53 Larry’s Diary, Jan 1951

1.54 Larry’s Diary, Feb 1951

1.55 Larry’s Diary, Mar 1951

1.56 1951 • Popcorn Girl

1.57 Larry’s Diary, Apr 1951

1.58 Billet-doux from Mom

1.59 Larry’s Diary, May 1951

1.60 Larry’s Diary, Jun 1951

1.61 Larry’s Diary, Jul 1951

1.62 Not MY Mother

1.63 Larry’s Diary, Aug 1951

1.64 Larry’s Diary, Sep 1951

1.65 Larry’s Diary, Oct 1951

1.66 Larry’s Diary, Nov-Dec 1951

1.67 Larry’s Diary, Jan 1952

1.68 Larry’s Diary, Feb 1952

1.69 Larry’s Diary, Mar 1952

1.70 Larry’s Diary, Apr 1952

1.71 Umpteenth Time

1.72 Larry’s Diary, May 1952

1.73 Letter from Mom to Verda

1.74 Larry’s Diary, Jun 1952

1.75 Tennis and Tonsils

1.76 Larry’s Diary, Jul 1952

1.77 Larry’s Diary, Aug 1952

1.78 Larry’s Diary, Sep 1952

1.79 2nd Letter to Verda

1.80 Larry’s Diary, Oct-Nov 1952

1.81 Larry’s Diary, Dec 1952

1.82 Carleen & Chuck, 1952-53

1.83 Mom’s Letter to Nellie, Mar 1953

1.84 A Wedding and Graduation, 1953

1.85 Summer Solstice, 1953 (1)

1.86 Summer Solstice, 1953 (2)

1.87 Summer 1953, Minnesota

1.88 From Betty’s Best Friend

1.89 Pick-Up Stix, Sep 1953

1.90 Larry’s Diary, Misc Entries 1953

1.91 Private Matters, 1953-1954

History and Backstory

1.001 My Maternal Grandparents

1.002 Crazy Quilt

1.003 Canada, Cuba, or Bust

1.004 My Mother’s Father

1.005 Boucher Street, Chico

1.006 Sketches of Chatfield Clan

1.007 Sign of the Cross

1.008 Golden Eagle Cafe

1.009 Everything is a Gamble

1.010 Minnesota Catholics and Cows

1.011 The Clemens Farm (part 1)

1.012 The Clemens Farm (part 2)

1.013 The Clemens Farm (part 3)

1.014 Sketches of Clemens Family

1.015 Where Babies Come From

1.016 Letter from My Mother

1.017 The War Years

Copyright © 2025 Catherine Sevenau. All rights reserved. · Log in

%d